Save

Show Notes: Interview with Romantic Suspense Author Jennifer Crosswhite

In this episode of The Romantic Side of Suspense, host Sarah Hamricker welcomes bestselling author Jennifer Crosswhite for a deep and insightful conversation on writing authentic romantic suspense, crafting ordinary-yet-compelling heroes, and weaving high-stakes tension with emotional growth.

Jennifer, known for her love of the great outdoors and her richly layered suspense stories, shares how she balances romance and danger, where her plots originate, and what makes this genre endlessly fascinating.

Writing Romantic Suspense: Why It’s the Best (and Most Challenging) Genre

Jennifer and Sarah dive right in, celebrating what they both love about romantic suspense—the emotions, the tension, the romance, and of course, the satisfying endings where the bad guy gets caught and love wins.

But writing it? That’s another story.
Jennifer explains that romantic suspense is essentially two stories in one:

• The romantic arc—putting the hero and heroine together amid emotional complications
• The suspense arc—placing ordinary people into extraordinary, high-stakes situations

Blending these threads while keeping the plot believable yet intense is one of the genre’s biggest challenges.

Balancing Believability and Escalating Stakes

One theme that stands out is Jennifer’s focus on realistic suspense rooted in everyday vulnerabilities.
She discusses:

• How normal, relatable characters can be thrust into danger
• Writing high-stakes moments that still feel true to life
• Using “what’s the worst thing that could happen?” as a plotting tool
• Ensuring suspense escalates without crossing the line into implausibility

Jennifer shares memorable examples, including a stalker using a character’s friend’s social media posts to track them—something reviewers found chillingly realistic.

Stress, Danger, and Character Growth

The conversation explores how stressful circumstances reveal true character, both in fiction and real life. Jennifer loves using pressure, danger, and uncertainty as catalysts for:

• Emotional revelation
• Relational bonding
• Spiritual growth, especially in Christian romantic suspense
• Moments where her characters must rely on God for strength and direction

This “crucible of refinement” is a major hallmark of her stories.

Everyday People in Extraordinary Circumstances

Jennifer writes heroes and heroines who are not law enforcement or military professionals—they’re ordinary individuals caught in dangerous situations. She explains why:

• Readers relate deeply to characters who feel like “someone I could know”
• High stress pushes characters into growth they’d never face otherwise
• Realistic reactions make scenes more immersive and emotionally rich

While police officers and firefighters appear in her stories, the protagonists’ inexperience heightens both suspense and character development.

Staying Safe in a Digital World

Sarah and Jennifer take a brief—but meaningful—detour into online safety. They discuss:

• The dangers of oversharing online
• Raising teens to understand their digital footprints
• How predators can exploit social media
• How these realities inspire plausible suspense plots

Writers, they admit, are naturally prone to imagining worst-case scenarios—and putting those fears to good use in fiction.

Where Plot Ideas Come From

Jennifer’s inspiration can come from anywhere: news articles, everyday conversations, real-world stories, her own childhood experiences, and even dreams.

She describes her creative process as a “compost pile”—a collection of clippings, memories, observations, and curiosities that slowly break down into new story ideas. Separate scraps blend into fully formed plots over time.

Her book Off the Map, for example, was born from:

• A childhood camping memory
• A “road trip siblings” concept
• A reunited high school sweetheart idea
• Realistic modern stalking techniques

Individually small—but together, they created a compelling romantic suspense premise.

Final Thoughts

This episode offers writers, readers, and romantic suspense fans a rich behind-the-scenes look into Jennifer Crosswhite’s process and creative heart. From crafting believable danger to fostering spiritual growth through storytelling, Jennifer’s insights highlight why romantic suspense remains such a beloved—and meaningful—genre.

Stay tuned after the interview for an exclusive excerpt from Jennifer’s latest novel, Off the Map.

Listen to the podcast episode here: