✍️ Tandem Services Coaching and Editing: Five things your editor wishes you’d done first

Empowering you to write the stories of your heart and increasing your impact with a book.

Hello Reader,

Helpful information for your writing career each month

In this issue:

  • Craft: Five things your editor wishes you’d done first
  • Career: A category trick and a reality check
  • Commerce: When you know it’s not working but you don’t know why
  • Kudos!

October is when a lot of manuscripts get “finished.” The summer draft is done, the kids are back in school, and suddenly the question is: Now what?

For most of you, now what means an editor. So this month I want to talk about what to do before you hand it over, because the prep you do in the weeks before an edit changes what you get out of it.

Now on to the things to help your writing career.

Craft: Five things your editor wishes you’d done first

Here’s a secret from the other side of the desk. When a manuscript lands in my inbox, I can usually tell in the first ten pages whether the author did any prep. And the ones who did get a better edit for the same money.

Why? Because an editor’s time goes where the problems are. If I spend the first pass fixing things you could have fixed yourself, that’s time I’m not spending on the things only an editor can see. Story structure. Character arc. Whether your nonfiction argument actually builds from chapter to chapter. The saggy middle you’ve stopped noticing because you’ve read it forty times.

So let’s talk about what to do first.

1. Finish the back half like you finished the front half

I don’t take unfinished manuscripts. But there’s another kind of unfinished, and I see it all the time: the manuscript that’s technically complete but tells on itself around chapter 20. The first half has been revised six times. The second half has notes to self in brackets, a paragraph that trails off mid-thought, and a chapter that’s really an outline wearing a chapter’s clothes. AI prompts left in from where you copy and pasted. 😳

I get it. By the time you reach the ending, you’ve been living with this book for a year, and you’re tired. You can’t tell the difference between what’s in your head and what’s on the page.

But a developmental editor needs the ending to evaluate the beginning. For fiction, your Story Goal, your Dark Moment, and your Epiphany only make sense as a set. For nonfiction, I can’t tell whether your chapter structure holds or your theme actually develops if the last three chapters are sketches. Give the back half one more pass before you send it. Even a rough one.

2. Do one read-through as a reader, not a writer

Print it or send it to your Kindle or change the font. Anything that makes it look unfamiliar. Then read it start to finish without a pen. Don’t fix anything. Just notice where you got bored, where you got confused, and where you skipped ahead. Nonfiction writers, notice where you’d stop trusting the author or become skeptical if you were the reader.

Those spots are your notes to me. Which brings us to the next one.

3. Write a one-page brief

This is the single most useful thing you can send with your manuscript, and almost nobody does it. One page. Genre and subgenre (or, for nonfiction, category and the transformation you’re promising). Target reader. Two or three comp titles. Word count. And then the honest part: What worries you about this book? What do you already suspect isn’t working?

You’d be amazed how often the author already knows. “The middle drags.” “I’m not sure the romance is believable.” “I think chapter one starts too early.” Tell me. I’ll still find things you didn’t see, but I’ll get to them faster.

4. Clean up the mechanical stuff

Spellcheck. One file, not twelve. Double-spaced, standard font, chapters clearly marked. Consistent character names and terminology (yes, I have received a manuscript where the heroine changed her name in chapter 14 and nobody noticed). None of this is glamorous. All of it keeps your editor focused on your story instead of your formatting.

5. Know which edit you’re asking for

Developmental, line, copy, proof. They’re different jobs at different stages. A developmental edit will come back with typos and unpolished sentences because that’s not the job of a developmental edit; it’s a copyedit. A proofread won’t tell you that your argument falls apart in chapter 11; a proofread is only looking for errors. So make sure your expectations are aligned with the edit you requested.

Don’t worry about getting all five perfect. Even two of them puts you ahead.

Apply it!

  • Read your last three chapters. Do they look like the first three? If not, that’s your next revision pass.
  • Schedule your reader’s read-through. Block a weekend and don’t get bogged down in typos.
  • Draft your one-page brief. Start with the worry list. That’s the part that matters.
  • Open the file and check: one document, double-spaced, chapter headings, page breaks separating chapters instead of just hitting return a bunch of times, spellcheck run.
  • If you’ not sure what kind of edit you need, reply to this email and I’ll help you sort it out. Hint: Almost everyone benefits from a developmental edit, at least for their first several books.

Career: A category trick and a reality check

Two things this month, one small and one big.

The small one. When you publish on Amazon, you pick categories from a dropdown, and most authors grab whatever looks close and move on. That’s a mistake, because the difference between a competitive category and a quiet one can be the difference between page 1 and page 40 of search results. You can even choose “ghost” categories that don’t really exist on the readers’ side of things. That’s not going to help your book sales.

Kindlepreneur has a walkthrough on choosing categories from data instead of guessing. Twenty minutes, and it’s one of the few things you can change after publication.

The big one. If you’ve been on any writer forum lately, you’ve seen the AI panic and rumors: Agents are secretly using it to reject you. Publishers are replacing editors with it. Nobody will ever buy a human-written book again. Jane Friedman, who reports on this industry for a living, looked at what’s actually happening at agencies and publishing houses, and it doesn’t match the panic. Her piece is a must-read worth ten minutes: Writers’ AI Fears Often Run Ahead of the Facts.

My take? Keep writing. The people who will buy your book are still reading. Whew.

Commerce: When you know it’s not working, but you don’t know why

Sometimes the real problem with a manuscript is that you can’t tell what it needs. You’ve read it so many times you can’t see it anymore. Something’s off in the middle. The ending doesn’t land. Your critique partner said “it’s good” in that tone.

That’s what the Mini Blueprint is for.

Here’s how it works. I take your manuscript through my Blueprint framework, the same structural lens I use on full developmental edits, and then we get on a 90-minute call. You walk away with a clear, prioritized plan. Not a list of forty things. The three or four that matter most, in the order to tackle them.

It’s $595. If you’ve got a finished draft and a nagging feeling, this is the fastest way I know to turn the feeling into a fix. Reply to this email and we’ll find you a slot.

And a heads-up: I’ll have Black Friday deals next month (yes, it’s almost that time of year), so if you’re on the fence about anything, hang tight.

Kudos!

Dr. Gayle Civish released her spiritual memoir The Fiery Trail to Walking in Prayer: Following Your Personal Spiritual Experiences, a Psychological and Spiritual Teaching Memoir. If you’ve had experiences you couldn’t explain and are interested in a genuine and embodied spiritual life, you’ll enjoy this memoir at the crossroads of psychology and spirituality.

Debbie Flores released her Bible study Sacred Shaking: Hearing the Voice of God in the Storm. If you’re walking through a season of disruption and want to hear God’s voice more clearly, this book is for you.

​

If you’re one of my clients who has won an award, finaled in a contest, achieved bestseller status, has a new release, or hit some sales goals, let me know. I’d love to celebrate your wins with you!

📺 Tandem Services has a YouTube page! Check it out at YouTube.com/@TandemServices​

​

Want personalized writing advice?

​

Share a writing, editing, or publishing hurdle you have faced or a question you have and I will email you an autographed copy of Eat the Elephant: How to Write (and Finish!) Your Book One Bite at a Time and send you a personalized five-minute video. Click here to find out more.

​

Writing quote

I’m writing a first draft and reminding myself that I’m simply shoveling sand into a box so that later I can build castles. —Shannon Hale

Pressing on!

Jennifer

PS—You should assume any link in this Update is an affiliate link. It costs you nothing more but gives me a few pennies. 🙂

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *